Halbzeit: 0-2
Lucas Zelarayán 27, Gyasi Zardes 30 49, Youness Mokhtar 60
| h2h | 2023-11-26 | FC Cincinnati |  | 1-0 |  | Philadelphia Union | HF | |||
| h2h | 2023-09-17 | Philadelphia Union | | 2-2 | | FC Cincinnati | Grp.East | |||
| h2h | 2022-04-24 | FC Cincinnati | | 1-2 |  | Los Angeles FC | Grp.West | |||
| h2h | 2022-02-27 | Austin FC |  | 5-0 | | FC Cincinnati | Grp.West | |||
| h2h | 2020-07-12 | FC Cincinnati | | 0-4 |  | Columbus Crew | Grp.E | |||
| h2h | 2019-04-07 | FC Cincinnati | | 1-1 |  | Sporting KC | Grp.West | |||
| h2h | 2019-03-17 | FC Cincinnati | | 3-0 |  | Portland Timbers | Grp.West |
| h2h | 2023-10-08 | Atlanta United |  | 1-1 | | Columbus Crew | Grp.East | |||
| h2h | 2022-03-12 | Columbus Crew | | 2-1 |  | Toronto FC | Grp.East | |||
| h2h | 2020-09-24 | Columbus Crew | | 2-1 |  | Minnesota United | Grp.Eastern | |||
| h2h | 2020-07-12 | FC Cincinnati | | 0-4 | | Columbus Crew | Grp.E | |||
| h2h | 2019-04-25 | Columbus Crew | | 0-1 |  | DC United | Grp.A | |||
| h2h | 2018-04-15 | DC United | | 1-0 | | Columbus Crew | Grp.East | |||
| h2h | 2018-03-03 | Toronto FC | | 0-2 | | Columbus Crew | Grp.East | |||
| h2h | 2017-11-30 | Toronto FC | | 1-0 | | Columbus Crew | ||||
| h2h | 2017-10-22 | New York City FC |  | 2-2 | | Columbus Crew | Grp.East | |||
| h2h | 2017-07-27 | Philadelphia Union | | 3-0 | | Columbus Crew | Grp.East |
