| Total | 317 | 134 | (42%) | 81 | (26%) | 102 | (32%) |
| Heimspiele | 157 | 89 | (57%) | 39 | (25%) | 29 | (18%) |
| Auswärtsspiele | 160 | 45 | (28%) | 42 | (26%) | 73 | (46%) |
S | 2024-04-21 | New York City FC |  | 2-0 |  | DC United | W | ||
S | 2024-04-14 | New York City FC | | 2-0 |  | NE Revolution | W | ||
U | 2024-04-07 | New York City FC | | 1-1 |  | Atlanta United | W | ||
U | 2024-03-31 | Inter Miami CF |  | 1-1 | | New York City FC | W | ||
N | 2024-03-24 | FC Cincinnati |  | 1-0 | | New York City FC | W | ||
S | 2024-03-17 | New York City FC | | 2-1 |  | Toronto FC | W | ||
N | 2024-03-09 | New York City FC | | 1-2 |  | Portland Timbers | W | ||
N | 2024-03-03 | St. Louis City SC |  | 2-0 | | New York City FC | W | ||
N | 2024-02-25 | Charlotte FC |  | 1-0 | | New York City FC | W | ||
S | 2023-10-22 | New York City FC | | 1-0 |  | Chicago Fire | SP9 | ||
N | 2023-10-08 | DC United | | 2-0 | | New York City FC | SP9 | ||
U | 2023-10-01 | Inter Miami CF | | 1-1 | | New York City FC | SP8 | ||
S | 2023-09-24 | New York City FC | | 3-0 | | Toronto FC | SP8 | ||
S | 2023-09-21 | New York City FC | | 2-0 |  | Orlando City | SP8 | ||
U | 2023-09-16 | New York City FC | | 0-0 |  | NY Red Bulls | SP8 | ||
U | 2023-09-02 | New York City FC | | 1-1 |  | Vancouver Whitecaps | SP8 | ||
S | 2023-08-31 | New York City FC | | 2-0 |  | CF Montréal | SP7 | ||
N | 2023-08-27 | FC Cincinnati | | 3-0 | | New York City FC | SP7 | ||
N | 2023-08-21 | New York City FC | | 0-2 |  | Minnesota United | SP7 | ||
N | 2023-07-16 | Philadelphia Union |  | 2-1 | | New York City FC | SP6 |
