Halbzeit: 2-2
 | The referee whistles for the end of the match | |
| 90' |  | NY Red Bulls: Victor Pálsson(in) - Dane Richards(out) |
| 86' |  | Rafa Márquez (NY Red Bulls) is shown a yellow card |
| 80' | | SJ Earthquakes: Ike Opara(in) - Ramiro Corrales(out) |
| 61' | | NY Red Bulls: Joel Lindpere(in) - Mehdi Ballouchy(out) |
| 59' | | NY Red Bulls: Connor Lade(in) - Roy Miller(out) |
| 52' | | Marvin Chávez (SJ Earthquakes) is shown a yellow card |
| 47' | | Dane Richards (NY Red Bulls) is shown a yellow card |
 | 2nd half begins | |
| 45' | | SJ Earthquakes: Jason Hernández(in) - Víctor Bernárdez(out) |
| 45' | | SJ Earthquakes: Simon Dawkins(in) - Víctor Bernárdez(out) |
 | The 1st half ends | |
| 35' |  | GOAL SJ Earthquakes: Chris Wondolowski (SJ Earthquakes) scores! |
| 25' | | Shea Salinas (SJ Earthquakes) is shown a yellow card |
| 23' | | GOAL NY Red Bulls: Dax McCarty (NY Red Bulls) scores! |
| 15' 0-0 | | GOAL SJ Earthquakes: Rafael Baca (SJ Earthquakes) scores! |
| 5' | | GOAL NY Red Bulls: Kenny Cooper (NY Red Bulls) scores! |
 | The match begins | |
